Best Ever Buttercream Frosting
Print This Recipe
This frosting reminds me of the kind you get on bakery sheet cakes. It’s delicious, easy to pipe, and easy to spread.
Ingredients
1/2 cup butter
1/2 cup butter flavor Crisco
1/8 teaspoon salt
1 1/2 teaspoons vanilla extract
5 cups confectioners’ sugar
1/4 cup milk
Preparation
In a large bowl, cream butter and shortening until light and fluffy. Add salt, vanilla, confectioners’ sugar and milk. Beat well.
Frosting Note:
The first time I made this frosting, I used regular water based food coloring and the colors came out extremely muted. Since then, I’ve used gel color and the colors have looked great.
Recipe from All Recipes.
Comments
14 Responses to “Best Ever Buttercream Frosting”
Leave a comment.
instead of using 1/2 crisco and 1/2 butter, can you just use all butter? what does the crisco do- is it to make it healthier?
thanks!
meredith…
Yes – this is the best buttercream frosting ever! It’s just what I’ve been looking for! And your pink and purple cakes are sooo cute!
[...] http://noshwithme.com/2005/10/best-ever-buttercream-frosting/ [...]
Can you make this into a chocolate frosting by adding cocoa powder? Or is that just a really dumb idea?
DC, I believe you can. In fact, I think I remember people talking about that on All Recipes.
Will the butter and butter flavored Crisco make the frosting look yellowish/ivory when it’s ready? What if I want a white buttercream frosting?
if you want white buttercream do not use the butter flavored crisco. It will make the icing a yellowish color. If you want white icing, use white crisco only
I have been told that you can also use clear vanilla extract and clear imitation butter flavoring to add to the whiteness of the cake… have not yet tried that… but have it from good source (:
I am sorry, but I didn’t think this was the “best ever” frosting at all. I think it has too much sugar in it. I’ve seen other similar recipes that call for less sugar. It overpowers the taste of the butter/crisco. I am not a novice baker either. It just wasn’t my favorite.
Oh, and to DC…that is not a dumb question at all. You can add cocoa to make it chocolate, but you might want to do a search for it to get the proper measurements. I’ve also seen it with melted chocolate in it.
Well, I did the recipe to a tee, and once they cooled they were like hard, dense, little hockey bucks. NOT light and fluffy like I had imagined. Hopefully the kids at my daughters school won’t notice how bad they really are. Sorry, the recipe gets a thumbs down from me. Maybe there are just 1 too many eggs.
Sorry, my last comment was for the cupcakes to go with this frosting. The frosting is perfect!
[...] tops and did not fall flat after I took them out of the oven. I used this recipe for the cake and this recipe for the butter cream. I filled them with blackberry jam. I tried to fill them with a tiny pastry [...]
Crisco is so that it won’t melt in summertime. Have you ever traveled in the heat with buttercream? What a mess.